ADC Home > Reference Library > Reference > Mac OS X > Mac OS X Man Pages

 

This document is a Mac OS X manual page. Manual pages are a command-line technology for providing documentation. You can view these manual pages locally using the man(1) command. These manual pages come from many different sources, and thus, have a variety of writing styles.

For more information about the manual page format, see the manual page for manpages(5).



Regexp::Common::comment(3)           User Contributed Perl Documentation          Regexp::Common::comment(3)



NAME
       Regexp::Common::comment -- provide regexes for comments.

SYNOPSIS
           use Regexp::Common qw /comment/;

           while (<>) {
               /$RE{comment}{C}/       and  print "Contains a C comment\n";
               /$RE{comment}{C++}/     and  print "Contains a C++ comment\n";
               /$RE{comment}{PHP}/     and  print "Contains a PHP comment\n";
               /$RE{comment}{Java}/    and  print "Contains a Java comment\n";
               /$RE{comment}{Perl}/    and  print "Contains a Perl comment\n";
               /$RE{comment}{awk}/     and  print "Contains an awk comment\n";
               /$RE{comment}{HTML}/    and  print "Contains an HTML comment\n";
           }

           use Regexp::Common qw /comment RE_comment_HTML/;

           while (<>) {
               $_ =~ RE_comment_HTML() and  print "Contains an HTML comment\n";
           }

DESCRIPTION
       Please consult the manual of Regexp::Common for a general description of the works of this interface.

       Do not use this module directly, but load it via Regexp::Common.

       This modules gives you regular expressions for comments in various languages.

       THE LANGUAGES

       Below, the comments of each of the languages are described.  The patterns are available as
       $RE{comment}{LANG}, foreach language LANG. Some languages have variants; it's described at the
       individual languages how to get the patterns for the variants.  Unless mentioned otherwise, "{-keep}"
       sets $1, $2, $3 and $4 to the entire comment, the opening marker, the content of the comment, and the
       closing marker (for many languages, the latter is a newline) respectively.

       ABC Comments in ABC start with a backslash ("\"), and last till the end of the line.  See
           <http://homepages.cwi.nl/%7Esteven/abc/.

       Ada Comments in Ada start with "--", and last till the end of the line.

       Advisor
           Advisor is a language used by the HP product glance. Comments for this language start with either
           "#" or "//", and last till the end of the line.

       Advsys
           Comments for the Advsys language start with ";" and last till the end of the line. See also
           <http://www.wurb.com/if/devsys/12.

       Alan
           Alan comments start with "--", and last till the end of the line.  See also
           <http://w1.132.telia.com/~u13207378/alan/manual/alanTOC.html.

       Algol 60
           Comments in the Algol 60 language start with the keyword "comment", and end with a ";". See
           <http://www.masswerk.at/algol60/report.htm.

       Algol 68
           In Algol 68, comments are either delimited by "#", or by one of the keywords "co" or "comment".
           The keywords should not be part of another word. See
           <http://westein.arb-phys.uni-dortmund.de/~wb/a68s.txt.  With "{-keep}", only $1 will be set,
           returning the entire comment.

       ALPACA
           The ALPACA language has comments starting with "/*" and ending with "*/".

       awk The awk programming language uses comments that start with "#" and end at the end of the line.

       B   The B language has comments starting with "/*" and ending with "*/".

       BASIC
           There are various forms of BASIC around. Currently, we only support the variant supported by
           mvEnterprise, whose pattern is available as $RE{comment}{BASIC}{mvEnterprise}. Comments in this
           language start with a "!", a "*" or the keyword "REM", and end till the end of the line. See
           <http://www.rainingdata.com/products/beta/docs/mve/50/ReferenceManual/Basic.pdf.

       Beatnik
           The esotoric language Beatnik only uses words consisting of letters.  Words are scored according
           to the rules of Scrabble. Words scoring less than 5 points, or 18 points or more are considered
           comments (although the compiler might mock at you if you score less than 5 points).  Regardless
           whether "{-keep}", $1 will be set, and set to the entire comment. This pattern requires perl
           5.8.0 or newer.

       beta-Juliet
           The beta-Juliet programming language has comments that start with "//" and that continue till the
           end of the line. See also <http://www.catseye.mb.ca/esoteric/b-juliet/index.html.

       Befunge-98
           The esotoric language Befunge-98 uses comments that start and end with a ";". See
           <http://www.catseye.mb.ca/esoteric/befunge/98/spec98.html.

       BML BML, or Better Markup Language is an HTML templating language that uses comments starting with
           "<?c_", and ending with "c_?>".  See <http://www.livejournal.com/doc/server/bml.index.html.

       Brainfuck
           The minimal language Brainfuck uses only eight characters, "<", ">", "[", "]", "+", "-", "." and
           ",".  Any other characters are considered comments. With "{-keep}", $1 is set to the entire
           comment.

       C   The C language has comments starting with "/*" and ending with "*/".

       C-- The C-- language has comments starting with "/*" and ending with "*/".  See
           <http://cs.uas.arizona.edu/classes/453/programs/C--Spec.html.

       C++ The C++ language has two forms of comments. Comments that start with "//" and last till the end
           of the line, and comments that start with "/*", and end with "*/". If "{-keep}" is used, only $1
           will be set, and set to the entire comment.

       C#  The C# language has two forms of comments. Comments that start with "//" and last till the end of
           the line, and comments that start with "/*", and end with "*/". If "{-keep}" is used, only $1
           will be set, and set to the entire comment.  See
           <http://msdn.microsoft.com/library/default.asp?url=/library/en-us/csspec/html/vclrfcsharpspec_C.asp.

       Caml
           Comments in Caml start with "(*", end with "*)", and can be nested.  See
           <http://www.cs.caltech.edu/courses/cs134/cs134b/book.pdf and
           <http://pauillac.inria.fr/caml/index-eng.html.

       Cg  The Cg language has two forms of comments. Comments that start with "//" and last till the end of
           the line, and comments that start with "/*", and end with "*/". If "{-keep}" is used, only $1
           will be set, and set to the entire comment.  See <http://developer.nvidia.com/attach/3722.

       CLU In "CLU", a comment starts with a procent sign ("%"), and ends with the next newline. See
           <ftp://ftp.lcs.mit.edu:/pub/pclu/CLU-syntax.ps and <http://www.pmg.lcs.mit.edu/CLU.html.

       COBOL
           Traditionally, comments in COBOL are indicated by an asteriks in the seventh column. This is what
           the pattern matches. Modern compiler may more lenient though. See
           <http://www.csis.ul.ie/cobol/Course/COBOLIntro.htm, and
           <http://www.csis.ul.ie/cobol/default.htm. Due to a bug in the regexp engine of perl 5.6.x, this
           regexp is only available in version 5.8.0 and up.

       CQL Comments in the chess query language (CQL) start with a semi colon (";") and last till the end of
           the line. See <http://www.rbnn.com/cql/.

       Crystal Report
           The formula editor in Crystal Reports uses comments that start with "//", and end with the end of
           the line.

       Dylan
           There are two types of comments in Dylan. They either start with "//", or are nested comments,
           delimited with "/*" and "*/".  Under "{-keep}", only $1 will be set, returning the entire
           comment.  This pattern requires perl 5.6.0 or newer.

       ECMAScript
           The ECMAScript language has two forms of comments. Comments that start with "//" and last till
           the end of the line, and comments that start with "/*", and end with "*/". If "{-keep}" is used,
           only $1 will be set, and set to the entire comment. JavaScript is Netscapes implementation of
           ECMAScript. See <http://www.ecma-international.org/publications/files/ecma-st/Ecma-262.pdf, and
           <http://www.ecma-international.org/publications/standards/Ecma-262.htm.

       Eiffel
           Eiffel comments start with "--", and last till the end of the line.

       False
           In False, comments start with "{" and end with "}".  See
           <http://wouter.fov120.com/false/false.txt

       FPL The FPL language has two forms of comments. Comments that start with "//" and last till the end
           of the line, and comments that start with "/*", and end with "*/". If "{-keep}" is used, only $1
           will be set, and set to the entire comment.

       Forth
           Comments in Forth start with "\", and end with the end of the line.  See also
           <http://docs.sun.com/sb/doc/806-1377-10.

       Fortran
           There are two forms of Fortran. There's free form Fortran, which has comments that start with
           "!", and end at the end of the line.  The pattern for this is given by $RE{Fortran}. Fixed form
           Fortran, which has been obsoleted, has comments that start with "C", "c" or "*" in the first
           column, or with "!" anywhere, but the sixth column.  The pattern for this are given by
           $RE{Fortran}{fixed}.

           See also <http://www.cray.com/craydoc/manuals/007-3692-005/html-007-3692-005/.

       Funge-98
           The esotoric language Funge-98 uses comments that start and end with a ";".

       fvwm2
           Configuration files for fvwm2 have comments starting with a "#" and lasting the rest of the line.

       Haifu
           Haifu, an esotoric language using haikus, has comments starting and ending with a ",".  See
           <http://www.dangermouse.net/esoteric/haifu.html.

       Haskell
           There are two types of comments in Haskell. They either start with at least two dashes, or are
           nested comments, delimited with "{-" and "-}".  Under "{-keep}", only $1 will be set, returning
           the entire comment.  This pattern requires perl 5.6.0 or newer.

       HTML
           In HTML, comments only appear inside a comment declaration.  A comment declaration starts with a
           "<!", and ends with a ">". Inside this declaration, we have zero or more comments.  Comments
           starts with "--" and end with "--", and are optionally followed by whitespace. The pattern
           $RE{comment}{HTML} recognizes those comment declarations (and hence more than a comment).  Note
           that this is not the same as something that starts with "<!--" and ends with "-->", because the
           following will be matched completely:

               <!--  First  Comment   --
                 --> Second Comment <!--
                 --  Third  Comment   -->

           Do not be fooled by what your favourite browser thinks is an HTML comment.

           If "{-keep}" is used, the following are returned:

           $1  captures the entire comment declaration.

           $2  captures the MDO (markup declaration open), "<!".

           $3  captures the content between the MDO and the MDC.

           $4  captures the (last) comment, without the surrounding dashes.

           $5  captures the MDC (markup declaration close), ">".

       Hugo
           There are two types of comments in Hugo. They either start with "!" (which cannot be followed by
           a "\"), or are nested comments, delimited with "!\" and "\!".  Under "{-keep}", only $1 will be
           set, returning the entire comment.  This pattern requires perl 5.6.0 or newer.

       Icon
           Icon has comments that start with "#" and end at the next new line.  See
           <http://www.toolsofcomputing.com/IconHandbook/IconHandbook.pdf,
           <http://www.cs.arizona.edu/icon/index.htm, and
           <http://burks.bton.ac.uk/burks/language/icon/index.htm.

       ILLGOL
           The esotoric language ILLGOL uses comments starting with NB and lasting till the end of the line.
           See <http://www.catseye.mb.ca/esoteric/illgol/index.html.

       INTERCAL
           Comments in INTERCAL are single line comments. They start with one of the keywords "NOT" or
           "N'T", and can optionally be preceeded by the keywords "DO" and "PLEASE". If both keywords are
           used, "PLEASE" preceeds "DO". Keywords are separated by whitespace.

       J   The language J uses comments that start with "NB.", and that last till the end of the line. See
           <http://www.jsoftware.com/books/help/primer/contents.htm, and <http://www.jsoftware.com/.

       Java
           The Java language has two forms of comments. Comments that start with "//" and last till the end
           of the line, and comments that start with "/*", and end with "*/". If "{-keep}" is used, only $1
           will be set, and set to the entire comment.

       JavaScript
           The JavaScript language has two forms of comments. Comments that start with "//" and last till
           the end of the line, and comments that start with "/*", and end with "*/". If "{-keep}" is used,
           only $1 will be set, and set to the entire comment. JavaScript is Netscapes implementation of
           ECMAScript.  See <http://www.mozilla.org/js/language/E262-3.pdf, and
           <http://www.mozilla.org/js/language/.

       LaTeX
           The documentation language LaTeX uses comments starting with "%" and ending at the end of the
           line.

       Lisp
           Comments in Lisp start with a semi-colon (";") and last till the end of the line.

       LPC The LPC language has comments starting with "/*" and ending with "*/".

       LOGO
           Comments for the language LOGO start with ";", and last till the end of the line.

       lua Comments for the lua language start with "--", and last till the end of the line. See also
           <http://www.lua.org/manual/manual.html.

       M, MUMPS
           In "M" (aka "MUMPS"), comments start with a semi-colon, and last till the end of a line. The
           language specification requires the semi-colon to be preceeded by one or more linestart
           characters.  Those characters default to a space, but that's configurable. This requirement, of
           preceeding the comment with linestart characters is not tested for. See
           <ftp://ftp.intersys.com/pub/openm/ism/ism64docs.zip,
           <http://mtechnology.intersys.com/mproducts/openm/index.html, and
           <http://mcenter.com/mtrc/index.html.

       mutt
           Configuration files for mutt have comments starting with a "#" and lasting the rest of the line.

       Nickle
           The Nickle language has one line comments starting with "#" (like Perl), or multiline comments
           delimited by "/*" and "*/" (like C). Under "-keep", only $1 will be set. See also
           <http://www.nickle.org.

       Oberon
           Comments in Oberon start with "(*" and end with "*)".  See
           <http://www.oberon.ethz.ch/oreport.html.

       Pascal
           There are many implementations of Pascal. This modules provides pattern for comments of several
           implementations.

           $RE{comment}{Pascal}
               This is the pattern that recognizes comments according to the Pascal ISO standard. This
               standard says that comments start with either "{", or "(*", and end with "}" or "*)". This
               means that "{*)" and "(*}" are considered to be comments. Many Pascal applications don't
               allow this.  See <http://www.pascal-central.com/docs/iso10206.txt

           $RE{comment}{Alice}
               The Alice Pascal compiler accepts comments that start with "{" and end with "}". Comments are
               not allowed to contain newlines.  See <http://www.templetons.com/brad/alice/language/.

           $RE{comment}{Pascal}{Delphi}, $RE{comment}{Pascal}{Free} and $RE{comment}{Pascal}{GPC}
               The Delphi Pascal, Free Pascal and the Gnu Pascal Compiler implementations of Pascal all have
               comments that either start with "//" and last till the end of the line, are delimited with
               "{" and "}" or are delimited with "(*" and "*)". Patterns for those comments are given by
               $RE{comment}{Pascal}{Delphi}, $RE{comment}{Pascal}{Free} and $RE{comment}{Pascal}{GPC}
               respectively. These patterns only set $1 when "{-keep}" is used, which will then include the
               entire comment.

               See <http://info.borland.com/techpubs/delphi5/oplg/,
               <http://www.freepascal.org/docs-html/ref/ref.html and <http://www.gnu-pascal.de/gpc/.

           $RE{comment}{Pascal}{Workshop}
               The Workshop Pascal compiler, from SUN Microsystems, allows comments that are delimited with
               either "{" and "}", delimited with "(*)" and "*"), delimited with "/*", and "*/", or starting
               and ending with a double quote ("""). When "{-keep}" is used, only $1 is set, and returns the
               entire comment.

               See <http://docs.sun.com/db/doc/802-5762.

       PEARL
           Comments in PEARL start with a "!" and last till the end of the line, or start with "/*" and end
           with "*/". With "{-keep}", $1 will be set to the entire comment.

       PHP Comments in PHP start with either "#" or "//" and last till the end of the line, or are delimited
           by "/*" and "*/". With "{-keep}", $1 will be set to the entire comment.

       PL/B
           In PL/B, comments start with either "." or ";", and end with the next newline. See
           <http://www.mmcctech.com/pl-b/plb-0010.htm.

       PL/I
           The PL/I language has comments starting with "/*" and ending with "*/".

       PL/SQL
           In PL/SQL, comments either start with "--" and run till the end of the line, or start with "/*"
           and end with "*/".

       Perl
           Perl uses comments that start with a "#", and continue till the end of the line.

       Portia
           The Portia programming language has comments that start with "//", and last till the end of the
           line.

       Python
           Python uses comments that start with a "#", and continue till the end of the line.

       Q-BAL
           Comments in the Q-BAL language start with "`" (a backtick), and contine till the end of the line.

       QML In "QML", comments start with "#" and last till the end of the line.  See
           <http://www.questionmark.com/uk/qml/overview.doc.

       R   The statistical language R uses comments that start with a "#" and end with the following new
           line. See <http://www.r-project.org/.

       REBOL
           Comments for the REBOL language start with ";" and last till the end of the line.

       Ruby
           Comments in Ruby start with "#" and last till the end of the time.

       Scheme
           Scheme comments start with ";", and last till the end of the line.  See <http://schemers.org/.

       shell
           Comments in various shells start with a "#" and end at the end of the line.

       Shelta
           The esotoric language Shelta uses comments that start and end with a ";". See
           <http://www.catseye.mb.ca/esoteric/shelta/index.html.

       SLIDE
           The SLIDE language has two froms of comments. First there is the line comment, which starts with
           a "#" and includes the rest of the line (just like Perl). Second, there is the multiline, nested
           comment, which are delimited by "(*" and "*)". Under C{-keep}>, only $1 is set, and is set to the
           entire comment. This pattern needs at least Perl version 5.6.0. See
           <http://www.cs.berkeley.edu/~ug/slide/docs/slide/spec/spec_frame_intro.shtml.

       slrn
           Configuration files for slrn have comments starting with a "%" and lasting the rest of the line.

       Smalltalk
           Smalltalk uses comments that start and end with a double quote, """.

       SMITH
           Comments in the SMITH language start with ";", and last till the end of the line.

       Squeak
           In the Smalltalk variant Squeak, comments start and end with """. Double quotes can appear inside
           comments by doubling them.

       SQL Standard SQL uses comments starting with two or more dashes, and ending at the end of the line.

           MySQL does not follow the standard. Instead, it allows comments that start with a "#" or "-- "
           (that's two dashes and a space) ending with the following newline, and comments starting with
           "/*", and ending with the next ";" or "*/" that isn't inside single or double quotes. A pattern
           for this is returned by $RE{comment}{SQL}{MySQL}. With "{-keep}", only $1 will be set, and it
           returns the entire comment.

       Tcl In Tcl, comments start with "#" and continue till the end of the line.

       TeX The documentation language TeX uses comments starting with "%" and ending at the end of the line.

       troff
           The document formatting language troff uses comments starting with "\"", and continuing till the
           end of the line.

       vi  In configuration files for the editor vi, one can use comments starting with """, and ending at
           the end of the line.

       *W  In the language *W, comments start with "||", and end with "!!".

       zonefile
           Comments in DNS zonefiles start with ";", and continue till the end of the line.

REFERENCES
       [Go 90]
           Charles F. Goldfarb: The SGML Handbook. Oxford: Oxford University Press. 1990. ISBN
           0-19-853737-9. Ch. 10.3, pp 390-391.

HISTORY
        $Log: comment.pm,v $
        Revision 2.116  2005/03/16 00:00:02  abigail
        CQL, INTERCAL, R

        Revision 2.115  2005/01/09 23:12:03  abigail
        BML comments

        Revision 2.114  2004/12/18 11:43:06  abigail
        POD: HTML comments end in >, not <

        Revision 2.113  2004/12/15 22:06:51  abigail
        Fixed regex for J comments

        Revision 2.112  2004/06/09 21:44:48  abigail
        New languages

        Revision 2.111  2003/09/24 08:39:35  abigail
        Stupid "syntax" warning issues false positives

        Revision 2.110  2003/08/19 21:27:55  abigail
        Nickle language

        Revision 2.109  2003/08/13 10:07:39  abigail
        Added patterns for C--, C#, Cg and SLIDE comments

        Revision 2.108  2003/08/01 11:30:25  abigail
        Comments for 'QML' and 'PL/SQL'

        Revision 2.107  2003/05/25 21:33:48  abigail
        POD nits from Bryan C. Warnock

        Revision 2.106  2003/03/12 22:25:42  abigail
        - More generic setup to define comments for various languages.
        - Expanded and redid the documentation for comment.pm.
        - Comments for Advisor, Advsys, Alan, Algol 60, Algol 68, B,
          BASIC (mvEnterprise), Forth, Fortran (both fixed and free form),
          fvwm2, mutt, Oberon, 6 versions of Pascal,
          PEARL (one of the at least four...), PL/B, PL/I, slrn, Squeak.

        Revision 2.105  2003/03/09 19:04:42  abigail
        - More generic setup to define comments for various languages.
        - Expanded and redid the documentation for comment.pm.
          Now every language has its own paragraph, describing its comment,
          and pointers to webpages.
        - Comments for Advisor, Advsys, Alan, Algol 60, Algol 68, B, BASIC
          (mvEnterprise), Forth, Fortran (both fixed and free form), fvwm2, mutt,
          Oberon, 6 versions of Pascal, PEARL (one of the at least four...), PL/B,
          PL/I, slrn, Squeak.

        Revision 2.104  2003/02/21 14:48:06  abigail
        Crystal Reports

        Revision 2.103  2003/02/11 09:39:08  abigail
        Added

        Revision 2.102  2003/02/07 15:23:54  abigail
        Lua and FPL

        Revision 2.101  2003/02/01 22:55:31  abigail
        Changed Copyright years

        Revision 2.100  2003/01/21 23:19:40  abigail
        The whole world understands RCS/CVS version numbers, that 1.9 is an
        older version than 1.10. Except CPAN. Curse the idiot(s) who think
        that version numbers are floats (in which universe do floats have
        more than one decimal dot?).
        Everything is bumped to version 2.100 because CPAN couldn't deal
        with the fact one file had version 1.10.

        Revision 1.19  2002/11/06 13:51:34  abigail
        Minor POD changes.

        Revision 1.18  2002/09/18 18:13:01  abigail
        Fixes for 5.005

        Revision 1.17  2002/09/04 17:04:24  abigail
        Q-BAL

        Revision 1.16  2002/08/27 16:50:50  abigail
        Patterns for Beatnik, Befunge-98, Funge-98 and W*.

        Revision 1.15  2002/08/22 17:04:03  abigail
        SMITH added

        Revision 1.14  2002/08/22 16:41:25  abigail
        + Added function 'id' and 'from_to' with associated data.
        + Added function 'combine' for languages having multiple syntaxes.
        + Added 'Shelta'

        Revision 1.13  2002/08/21 16:00:32  abigail
        beta-Juliet, Portia, ILLGOL and Brainfuck.

        Revision 1.12  2002/08/20 17:40:37  abigail
        - Created a 'nested' function (simplified version from
          Regexp::Common::balanced).
        - Comments that use 'from' to eol or balanced (nested) delimiters
          are now generated from a data array.
        - Added Hugo and Haifu.

        Revision 1.11  2002/08/05 12:16:58  abigail
        Fixed 'Regex::' and 'Rexexp::' typos to 'Regexp::'
        (Found my Mike Castle).

        Revision 1.10  2002/07/31 23:33:16  abigail
        Documented that Haskell and Dylan comments need at least 5.6.0.

        Revision 1.9  2002/07/31 23:12:29  abigail
        Dylan and Haskell comments can be nested, hence version 5.6.0 of Perl
        is needed to be able to make a regex matching them.

        Revision 1.8  2002/07/31 14:48:16  abigail
        Added LOGO (to please petdance)

        Revision 1.7  2002/07/31 13:06:41  abigail
        Dealt with -keep for Haskell and Dylan.

        Revision 1.6  2002/07/31 00:54:00  abigail
        Added comments for Haskell, Dylan, Smalltalk and MySQL.

        Revision 1.5  2002/07/30 16:38:23  abigail
        Added support for the languages: LaTeX, Tcl, TeX and troff.

        Revision 1.4  2002/07/26 16:48:12  abigail
        Simplied datastructure for the languages that use single line comments.

        Revision 1.3  2002/07/26 16:37:20  abigail
        Added new languages: Ada, awk, Eiffel, Java, LPC, PHP, Python,
        REBOL, Ruby, vi and zonefile.

        Revision 1.2  2002/07/25 22:37:44  abigail
        Added 'use strict'.
        Added 'no_defaults' to 'use Regex::Common' to prevent loaded of all
        defaults.

        Revision 1.1  2002/07/25 19:56:07  abigail
        Modularizing Regexp::Common.

SEE ALSO
       Regexp::Common for a general description of how to use this interface.

AUTHOR
       Damian Conway (damian@conway.org)

MAINTAINANCE
       This package is maintained by Abigail (regexp-common@abigail.nl).

BUGS AND IRRITATIONS
       Bound to be plenty.

       For a start, there are many common regexes missing.  Send them in to regexp-common@abigail.nl.

COPYRIGHT
            Copyright (c) 2001 - 2003, Damian Conway. All Rights Reserved.
              This module is free software. It may be used, redistributed
             and/or modified under the terms of the Perl Artistic License
                   (see http://www.perl.com/perl/misc/Artistic.html)



perl v5.8.8                                      2005-03-15                       Regexp::Common::comment(3)

Did this document help you?
Yes: Tell us what works for you.
It’s good, but: Report typos, inaccuracies, and so forth.
It wasn’t helpful: Tell us what would have helped.